Bloggers and marketers have new common ground: the proposed FTC regulations that, if enacted, will hold bloggers liable for product reviews. That could have some bloggers skittish about accepting your next product sample for review.
Blogger X says the product cleans your house, picks up your kids and puts dinner on the table. If the product doesn’t work the same way when you try it at home, you now have someone beside the product maker to blame - that nice mom blogger up the street, who, by the way, was just expressing an opinion, not writing a product manual. Check out NJ Mom Blogger Liz Thompson’s comments on the subject.
There’s something, no wait, there’s a lot that bothers me about the idea of mom bloggers like Liz having to hire legal counsel. But things may not be as bad as they sound. The proposed regulations are primarily aimed at curtailing pay-for-play posts - separating editorial and advertisement, as traditional media have historically done (though things do seem to be murkier every day with “advertorial” copy and product placement, not to mention celebrity endorsements).
The new regs would also hold brands liable, requiring brands to ensure information provided to bloggers is 100% accurate - and PR people don’t embellish the pitch beyond what the product truly delivers (not a bad thing, truth in advertising, truth in PR). The bigger challenge for brands would be traversing the blogosphere to make sure information delivered is accurately translated, as reviews are posted. No small task. Perhaps an opportunity for social media monitoring services, such as Radian6 (which we use) and more advanced tools, such as Trucast.
One positive that could come from all of this is the demise of pay-for-play agencies that promise to deliver XX number of positive reviews in XX days. They can guarantee the reviews because they’re buying them. I’ve been surprised at the level of brands who have subscribed to these models. Why not be transparent and just place real ads on blogs and at the same time earn the editorial and endorsements?
Some networks, like BlogHer, have put in place their own standards - requiring bloggers participating in their network to place advertising and editorial on different pages - and sometimes different blogs altogether (many bloggers have separate blogs for product reviews, though their readership is not always as strong as their main blog). That policy is meeting with mixed reviews, as some bloggers say they don’t want third-party groups controlling their blog.
I’m headed to NewComm Forum to join Susan Getgood on a blogger relations panel Monday, where the FTC regs promise to be a hot topic. Stay tuned for more here and keep an eye on Twitter #sncr for the discussion.
Filed under: Blogger Relations, Marketing to Moms by LauraTomasetti - 3 Comments →